Sanibel Highlands

Sanibel Neighborhoods

Inland, Mid-Island

About Sanibel Highlands

Sanibel Highlands

This large group of home sites range from smaller lots to some on Old Trail on more than 1 acre parcels. Owners enjoy mid island convenience to Sanibel shops, dining and more.

Community Details

Total Units

112

Minimum Rental

28 days

Deeded Beach Access

Active Listings in Sanibel Highlands

For sale

$875,000

( $500,000 on 2/20/2026)

475 Whitehall Road

Sanibel, FL 33957

1,677 sq ft | 2 beds | 2 baths

Single Family Residence

1,248 sq ft | 3 beds | 2 baths

Single Family Residence

For sale

$749,000

( $49,000 on 2/19/2026)

450 Birdsong Place

Sanibel, FL 33957

1,193 sq ft | 3 beds | 3 baths

Single Family Residence

Pending

$975,000

( $50,000 on 4/9/2025)

485 Peachtree Road

Sanibel, FL 33957

1,990 sq ft | 3 beds | 3 baths

Single Family Residence

For sale

$674,000

( $673,326 on 7/26/2025)

1657 Atlanta Plaza Drive

Sanibel, FL 33957

1,650 sq ft | 3 beds | 2 baths

Single Family Residence

Pending

$614,950

( $50,000 on 2/9/2026)

495 E Lake Road

Sanibel, FL 33957

1,152 sq ft | 3 beds | 2 baths

Single Family Residence

Interested in Sanibel Highlands?

Contact our team for more information about this community or to schedule a showing of available properties.

Virtual Tour

Gallery

5 Photos

1 of 5