Jonathan’s Bay in Fort Myers

Jonathan’s Bay is a gated coach-home community in South Fort Myers featuring 152 residences in a convenient location between Gladiolus Drive and US-41 (Tamiami Trail). The neighborhood is known for its lake-centered clubhouse setting, resort-style amenities, and easy access to beaches, shopping, dining, and Southwest Florida International Airport.

Jonathan’s Bay offers a balance of affordability, maintenance-free living, and community amenities, making it appealing to seasonal residents, full-time homeowners, and buyers seeking a convenient Fort Myers location near Sanibel Island and Fort Myers Beach.

Community Facts & Features

• 🏡 Community Type: Gated coach-home community

• 🏘️ Total Residences: Approximately 152 homes

• 📍 Location: South Fort Myers near Gladiolus Drive and US-41

• 🌊 Setting: Inland lake-view community

• 🏊 Community Pool and spa

• 🏛️ Lakeside clubhouse with social space

• 💪 Fitness center

• 🔒 Gated entry community

• 🌴 Tropical landscaping and walking areas

• 📅 Completed: Around 2006

• 📍 Latitude / Longitude: 26.4982, -81.9317 (approximate community entrance)

HOA fees typically include exterior maintenance, cable, internet, water, and community amenities, supporting a low-maintenance lifestyle for residents.

Community History

Jonathan’s Bay was developed by Transeastern Homes as a planned coach-home community in South Fort Myers during the mid-2000s. The neighborhood was designed around a central lake and clubhouse to create a social, walkable residential environment while maintaining easy access to regional destinations.

Since completion around 2006, Jonathan’s Bay has remained a well-maintained gated community known for its convenient location and reasonably priced homes compared to nearby coastal and golf-course neighborhoods.

Community Overview

Jonathan’s Bay consists primarily of coach-home style residences with attached garages, open floor plans, and screened lanais overlooking lakes or landscaped areas. Many homes include features such as high ceilings, modern kitchens, and spacious primary suites designed for comfortable Southwest Florida living.

The community’s layout centers around a large lake and clubhouse area, creating a natural gathering place for residents. The gated entrance and smaller community size contribute to a quiet, neighborhood-oriented atmosphere while still being close to major roadways and shopping centers.

Jonathan’s Bay is located approximately 1.5 miles south of Gladiolus Drive, providing convenient access to Sanibel Island, Fort Myers Beach, and surrounding Southwest Florida destinations.

Jonathan’s Bay Residents Enjoy

Residents enjoy a maintenance-friendly lifestyle with community amenities centered around the lakeside clubhouse. The pool, fitness center, and gathering spaces create opportunities for social interaction while maintaining a relaxed residential setting.

The South Fort Myers location makes Jonathan’s Bay appealing to buyers who want proximity to beaches and coastal destinations without the higher cost of waterfront communities.

Minutes To Nearby Destinations

Jonathan’s Bay offers convenient access to many Southwest Florida destinations:

⏱ 5 minutes to Gladiolus Drive shopping and dining
⏱ 10 minutes to HealthPark Medical Center
⏱ 15 minutes to Sanibel Causeway
⏱ 20 minutes to Fort Myers Beach
⏱ 25 minutes to Southwest Florida International Airport

(Drive times are approximate and may vary by traffic and season.)

Buying in Jonathan’s Bay

For buyers, Jonathan’s Bay offers a gated community lifestyle with amenities and maintenance services at a price point that is often more accessible than waterfront or golf-course communities in the Fort Myers area. The combination of location, clubhouse amenities, and coach-home design makes the neighborhood attractive to both seasonal residents and full-time homeowners.

Homes with lake views, updated interiors, and proximity to the clubhouse often generate strong buyer interest.

Selling in Jonathan’s Bay

For sellers, Jonathan’s Bay benefits from its location in South Fort Myers near beaches, medical services, and major roadways. Highlighting gated entry, clubhouse amenities, maintenance-included living, and attached garages can help listings stand out to buyers seeking convenience and value.

The community’s reputation as a well-maintained coach-home neighborhood continues to attract buyers looking for a balance of lifestyle and affordability.

Explore Homes in Jonathan’s Bay

View Jonathan’s Bay Homes for Sale Below

Interested in buying or selling in Jonathan’s Bay? Our local experts are here to help.

👉 Request a Private Showing
👉 Ask a Local Expert