Coconut Creek – Fort Myers Community Guide

Coconut Creek in Fort Myers

Coconut Creek is a gated residential community in the Iona area of South Fort Myers, located on McGregor Boulevard between Kelly Road and John Morris Road.

This quiet neighborhood sits just minutes from Sanibel Island and the beaches of Fort Myers, making it attractive to buyers who want a peaceful setting close to Southwest Florida’s waterfront lifestyle. The community blends classic Old Florida architecture with mature landscaping, lakes, and shaded streets.

Originally developed in the early 1990s on the historic Wesemeyer estate, Coconut Creek was designed to preserve the natural beauty of the property while creating a small, distinctive neighborhood of single-family homes.

Today, the community remains a hidden gem for buyers seeking a private location near the islands.

Location in the Iona Area of Fort Myers

Coconut Creek is situated in the desirable Iona neighborhood of South Fort Myers, an area known for its proximity to the Gulf and the barrier islands.

Nearby destinations include:

• Sanibel Island Causeway – approximately 10 minutes away

• Fort Myers Beach – about 20 minutes

• HealthPark Medical Center

• McGregor Boulevard riverfront corridor

• Shopping and dining along Summerlin Road

The community’s location also allows convenient access to boating, beaches, and nature preserves throughout the region.

Homes in Coconut Creek

Coconut Creek is a gated community of approximately 150 single-family homes built in the Old Florida architectural style.

Many homes feature:

• Metal roofs and large covered porches

• Open floor plans with spacious living areas

• Lake views or lush landscaped lots

• Mature palm trees, banyan trees, and oak canopy streets

The neighborhood was developed around two lakes, creating attractive water views and natural scenery throughout the community.

Homes vary in size but generally offer generous square footage and private outdoor spaces suited for Southwest Florida living.

Amenities and Neighborhood Features

Residents enjoy several shared amenities designed to support an active yet relaxed lifestyle.

Community amenities include:

• Gated entry

• Community pool and spa

• Tennis and pickleball courts

• Clubhouse gathering space

• Children’s playground

• Walking paths around the lakes

• Dog park

• Kayaking, paddleboarding, and canoeing opportunities on the lake

The neighborhood’s sidewalks and tree-lined streets also encourage walking, biking, and outdoor recreation.

A Quiet Neighborhood Near the Beaches

One of Coconut Creek’s biggest advantages is its location between Fort Myers and the islands. The community is roughly 3½ miles from the Sanibel Causeway, providing quick access to Sanibel Island’s beaches and wildlife refuges.

This proximity makes the neighborhood appealing to buyers who want easy access to:

• Shelling beaches on Sanibel

• Boating and fishing in the Gulf

• Wildlife viewing at J.N. “Ding” Darling National Wildlife Refuge

• Island dining and shopping

At the same time, residents enjoy the quieter residential atmosphere of the Iona area.

Why Buyers Consider Coconut Creek

Buyers exploring South Fort Myers often consider Coconut Creek for several reasons:

• Gated neighborhood with a limited number of homes

• Mature landscaping and Old Florida design character

• Lakefront views and natural surroundings

• Close proximity to Sanibel Island and Fort Myers Beach

• Convenient access to shopping, healthcare, and marinas

The community appeals to those seeking a balance between island proximity and a peaceful residential environment.

Coconut Creek Real Estate

Real estate in Coconut Creek consists primarily of single-family homes built in the 1990s and early 2000s. The neighborhood’s limited number of properties means homes do not come on the market frequently.

When listings appear, buyers are often drawn to:

• The gated setting

• Larger home sites compared to newer communities

• The classic Florida architectural style

• The location near Sanibel and the Gulf beaches

Learn More About Communities in the Iona Area in South Fort Myers

FUN FACT: Frederick J. Wesemeyer was a worldwide marketer of Gladiolus Bulbs and Flowers. Until his death in 1987, Wesemeyer was the controlling partner of A & W Bulb. He was born in Germany and came to America to follow in his father's footsteps as a florist. Coconut Creek was built on the 76 acre Wesemeyer estate in 1990 by Daniel Wayne Homes. Part of the original estate, the Coconut Creek Clubhouse is a state historic landmark. The Dodrill Family of Daniel Waynes Homes has been building communities in the Fort Myers area since 1970 and they are dedicated to the preservation of this historic piece of Fort Myers History.