By The Sea Condos for Sale on Sanibel Island

Gulf-Front Community Under Full Reconstruction

By The Sea condos for sale on Sanibel Island offer a rare opportunity to purchase into a Gulf-front community that is being rebuilt brand new, following full agreement among owners to move forward with reconstruction.

Located on West Gulf Drive, this property is transitioning from an older beachfront complex into a newly rebuilt, modernized residential community, creating a unique opportunity for buyers willing to participate in the final stages of construction.

By The Sea Condo Community Overview

By The Sea is a Gulf-front condominium community on Sanibel Island that is currently in the early stages of full reconstruction.

The community historically featured a low-density, residential-only environment with direct beach access and private amenities. Following storm damage, all owners agreed to rebuild the property, resulting in a coordinated redevelopment effort rather than piecemeal renovations.

Key Features (Planned / Historical):

• Direct Gulf-front location with beach access

• Low-density residential community

• Non-rental environment (historically)

• Planned restoration of pool, cabana, and common areas

• Covered parking and security features

The rebuilt version of By The Sea is expected to deliver a more modern, resilient structure, though final details may evolve during construction.

Looking to compare similar properties? Our Complete Guide to All Sanibel Condominium Communities. provides a full directory of Gulf-front, bayfront, and inland condo communities across Sanibel Island.

Full Community Rebuild: What Buyers Need to Know

By The Sea is not a typical resale purchase—it is a reconstruction investment opportunity.

• The building is currently in early reconstruction phases

• Purchase prices may reflect ownership interest only, not completed units

• Buyers are responsible for remaining construction and build-out costs

• Final layouts, finishes, and timelines are subject to change during construction

Estimated costs provided by the association indicate:

• Additional construction costs to deliver a “white box” unit

• Additional interior build-out costs depending on finishes

This type of purchase is best suited for buyers who:

• Understand construction timelines and variability

• Are comfortable with phased completion

• Are focused on long-term value rather than immediate use

What Makes By The Sea Unique

Full Owner Alignment on Rebuild

One of the most important aspects of this community:

• All owners agreed to rebuild

• No fragmented or inconsistent unit renovations

• A unified redevelopment plan

This is extremely rare among Sanibel condo communities post-storm and significantly reduces uncertainty compared to partially rebuilt properties.

Opportunity to Own “New Construction” on the Gulf

Unlike traditional resale condos, this offers:

• A newly rebuilt structure

• Updated building standards and resiliency

• The ability to customize interior finishes

This creates a hybrid between condo ownership and new construction.

Residential, Non-Rental Environment

By The Sea has historically been a non-rental community, preserving:

• A quiet, owner-occupied atmosphere

• Minimal turnover

• A more private beachfront experience

Low-Density Gulf-Front Living

The community offers:

• Fewer units than large complexes

• Less crowded beach and amenities

• A more residential feel

This is ideal for buyers prioritizing privacy.

Location Advantages (West-End Position)

By The Sea is located along West Gulf Drive on Sanibel’s desirable west end.

Nearby:

• Bowman’s Beach

• Blind Pass

• J.N. “Ding” Darling National Wildlife Refuge

• Scenic bike paths and nature areas

This area is known for its quiet beaches, natural surroundings, and reduced traffic.

Buyer Insights: Who This Community Is Perfect For

By The Sea is ideal for buyers seeking long-term value in a rebuilt Gulf-front property.

Compare Sanibel Condominium Communities

Buyers considering this community often compare multiple condo options across Sanibel Island, including Gulf-front, bayfront, and inland properties with different amenities, rental policies, and lifestyle appeal.

Our Complete Guide to All Sanibel Condominium Communities provides a full directory of every condo community on Sanibel, making it easy to explore and compare options based on location, views, and features.

Whether you're searching for a beachfront condo, a boating community, or a quieter inland setting, this guide helps you quickly identify the best fit for your goals.

Ideal Buyers:

• Buyers comfortable with construction timelines

• Those seeking newly rebuilt Gulf-front property

• Long-term investors focused on future value

• Buyers prioritizing privacy and residential environments

Not Ideal For:

• Buyers needing immediate occupancy

• Investors seeking short-term rental income

• Those uncomfortable with construction uncertainty

Real Estate Market Insight

By The Sea represents a different category of opportunity on Sanibel Island:

• Not a traditional resale

• Not fully completed new construction

• A phased rebuild with long-term upside

Post-storm redevelopment across Sanibel is creating opportunities for buyers willing to participate in the rebuilding process, often at pricing levels below finished product value.

By The Sea Real Estate

All By The Sea properties for sale are shown at the bottom of this page.

 View All Sanibel Condominiums for Sale

Contact Us for the most current HOA fees, reserves, meeting minutes & property taxes.

Final Takeaway

By The Sea offers a rare opportunity to purchase into a fully aligned Gulf-front rebuild, where all owners have committed to creating a new, modernized community.

For buyers who understand the construction process and are focused on long-term value, this property represents a chance to own effectively new Gulf-front real estate on Sanibel Island in a low-density, residential setting.